sábado, 22 de septiembre de 2007

Act 1 - Scenes 3 & 4

First of all, regarding Rita's view upon working-class culture I have to say that, although I agree with her on most of her ideas, I don't think that the working class has no culture at all. Of course that for deciding whether they have or not one I should first of all provide a definition for culture, so let's say that in this context, for me, culture entails everything that may result from the relationship and the exchanging obtained through the co-existence of people (language, behaviour, customs, habits, likes, dislikes, conflicts...). Considering this definition of culture, working class people do have their own culture. However, I do agree with Rita when she says that she sees 'everyone trying to ger from one day to the next,' she finds no meaning in this sort of life as they find themselves not living but surviving. She finds a very good way of explaining herself and showing what she means when she says that they have no culture. She gives the example of the Daily Mirror, The Sun and ITV bombarding people with ads for having them wanting more and more money to buy more and more things that they don't actually need but with which they try to convince themselves that they are happy when they are not...I found it really interesting when she says 'and the papers tell them what to spend the money on so the desease is always covered up.' (These absence of meaning, thoughts, beliefs, ideas and values in their lives is what Rita calls the desease)
Secondly, as regards what Rita learns by the end of these two scenes, I think that she learns to make connections. In fact, what she learns is the fact that she is perfectly able to make connections between many different things (her dresses, ITV, the Daily Mirror, addicts, her and her husband), and, as result of becoming aware of this, she will be able to start making connections for writing her essays.
Thridly, in my opinion, what is wrong with her essays is the fact that not only they are too short but they are also written quoting authors/writers that are not exactly writers of literature (here is when Rita learns that not every book is literature). However, I think that there is something more important that the mere fact that she's written them in this way: she hasn't taken enough time to prepare them, and here in when Frank learns more about Rita's life and her husband. He seems to be rather concerned about Rita's having to write her essays at home because of her husband's not allowing her to do it at home. This situation shows us more about Rita and her convictions: 'art and literature feed me inside... and Denny hates me comin' here. It's like drug addicts, they hate it when one of them tries to break away.' She knows that she is trying to break away, she is trying to break away from the meaningless and empty life that her husband is (and she was) living...
Finally, I think that Rita says that 'it makes me stronger coming here' simply because by doing so she is trying and fighting to get the life she wants for her...'I don't see any culture, I just see everyone pissed, or on Valium, trying to get from one day to the next. There's no meaning...' She is perfectly aware of what is going on with them and that's why she wants to do something. She wants to give herself the chance of breaking away and being different from those people (like her husband) that pretend to ignore what's going on, to ignore the desease.

'I just see everyone pissed, trying to get from one day to the next...Cos there's no meaning!'

3 comentarios:

Gladys Baya dijo...

I just love your discussion of the concept of culture here, Alejandra! I may add that this difference may crop up from the fact that, while we're referring to culture as "the system of standards of a given discourse community" (as defined by Kramsch 1998), Rita might be referring to "culture as civilization". Both meanings can be acceptable, as long as we don't think both concepts are the same! ;-)

As for your second point, I'm not sure I get you... What do you exactly mean when you say "Rita has learned to make connections"? :-?

Thinking about Rita and her husband: do you understand him? What is Rita saying about his own life when she looks down upon their (lack of) culture? Is Rita's way of seeing life the only "accurate" one?

All my love,
Gladys

AL dijo...

Hi Gladys!
Yes! You're right! I think that Rita's view upon culture has to do with what you wrote... 'Culture as Civilization'
I think that Rita feels sad and hopeless about the life that other people in her situation are living because, comparing her husband's life with the life of an 'animal' (in contrast with what makes us Human), she feels that there is no difference between them since the only thing that his husband (and the others in the same situation) is doing is surviving and not LIVING.
What makes us Human, as we have previously and almost endlessly discussed, is what Denny and the others are leaving behind: their feelings, their hopes, their capacity of reasoning and fighting for their dreams...
I 'know' that speaking a language distinguishes us from other animals. Anyway, I do believe that, even if we are able to use a language, the most important thing is not being able to use it but using it for SOMETHING, using it for LOVING, SHARING, SHOWING OUR FEELINGS, LIVING AS THE HUMAN BEING S WE ARE and not acting AS IF WE WERE HUMANS...

Gladys Baya dijo...

Can we safely assume Denny and her friends are not making choices, Alejandra (choices we might disagree with, definitely, but choices anyway!")? Is educating people about telling them what "the right choices" are?

During Act 2, you'll see Frank telling Rita "you've just found another song - and on your lips it's hollow and tuneless"... What might he be insinuating?

Food for thought...
Love,
Gladys